Court of Appeals for the First Circuit March 23, 1936, No. 3106 (H. Schindler & Co. v. C. Saladino & Sons, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-03-1936

lead-opinion

WILSON, Circuit Judge.

This is an appeal from the District Court of Massachusetts- holding invalid a patent, No. 1,970,376, granted to Walter J. Hamburger on August 14, 1934, and dismissing the complaint against the defendant-appellee for infringement, although the District Court found that, if valid, the defendant had infringed the patent.

The patent involved a process for making tennis strings of silk, with what is termed a “perfect spiral”; that is, with a strand of a different color from the body of the string, and displaying a visible spiral, regularly spaced, on the outside of and the entire length of the string.

The District Court held that, in view of the prior art, the process employed by the plaintiff-appellant in obtaining what is termed the “perfect spiral” was a mere exercise of mechanical skill, and did not constitute invention.

Silk strings for tennis rackets have come into use only within the last twelve or fifteen years. Prior to that time the strings for rackets were usually made entirely of gut. In making strings of gut, which contains in itself a natural binder, the ■ method is different from that when made of silk. In the manufacture of sill: tennis strings a slow drying colloidal binder is used, which remains tacky, or sticky, for some length of time after immersion in it, or a sufficient length of time to allow the several strands of silk to be twisted into a single string and to be bound closely together.

Gut strings for tennis rackets were usually made in their natural color. After silk came into use for the purpose, a popular demand arose for a strand of a brighter color than that of the body of the string, to be wound helically outside the body of the string and at regular intervals.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.