Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit January 28, 1936, No. 10321 (Butler Mfg. Co. v. Enterprise Cleaning Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1936

VAN VALKENBURGH, Circuit Judge.

This case involves a contest between systems employed in the dry cleaning of textile materials, such as soiled garments and the like. Appellant is the owner of three patents: The Fenton patent, No. 1,-669,235, issued May 8, 1928; the Hatfield patent, No. 1,704,604, issued March 5, 1929; and the Hatfield-Alliott patent, No. 1,728,-343, issued September 17, 1929. It is charged that three claims in each patent are infringed by the process employed by appellee Enterprise Cleaning Company, and recommended by appellee Filtration Products Company. The latter company accordingly sought and was granted leave to intervene, was made a defendant, and filed answer. The Fenton patent is for a “Dry Cleaning System.” The specification states that the invention has for its object economy in dry cleaning, and that it will substantially do away with the necessity of distilling the dry-cleaning fluid. It embraces both the process and the apparatus for accomplishing the stated results. Only process claims are here involved, to wit, Nos. 1, 11, and 14. Claim 1 reads as follows: “In dry-cleaning, the herein "described process which comprises subjecting soiled textile material containing greasy or oily material to the action of a volatile organic solvent which is substantially non-miscible with water; drawing off the solvent with accumulated impurities; agitating the said solvent carrying impurities together with a solid material insoluble therein, which material possesses good adsorbing properties; separating the solid adsorbing material with accumulated impurities from the said solvent by filtration; and returning the solvent free from said adsorbing material and adsorbed impurities in a substantially continuous manner to-the first-men•tioned step -of the process, until the said textile material has been cleaned to the desired extent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.