Supreme Court of New Jersey February 6, 1936 (Yedid v. Atlantic City)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-02-1936
Bodlne, J.
Relator seeks by mandamus to secure the right to slaughter poultry in the municipal poultry market of Atlantic City. His petition states that he has been employed to slaughter chickens by a number of persons engaged in the sale of kosher poultry. His employers do not have stores or stands in the municipal poultry market. Poultry may not be slaughtered elsewhere. The city, when it established the municipal poultry market, authorized the mayor to prepare rules and regulations providing for the control and use thereof, and for the rental and charges to be made, the rules and regulations to be first submitted for approval. Ho rules and regulations have been adopted, but the leases of the respective tenants all provide that there shall be a committee to promulgate rules and regulations controlling that part of the market devoted to the killing and sale of kosher products. The committee determined that all kosher products should *125be under the supervision of the Yead Ha’Kashress. .Relator seems not to have had the approval of this board.
Mandamus is a discretionary writ to issue only when the legal right is clear. It is obvious that the municipality was within its rights, when it incorporated in the leases granted to those having stores and stalls in the market, provisions providing for a committee to promulgate rules and regulations governing the killing and sale of products offered in the market. If relator conformed with these rules his right would be clear. Since he has not, his right to kill poultry in the municipal market must rest upon the right which he and all other citizens have to go to the municipal market for the purpose of slaughtering poultry. But he does not seek to enforce the right which he as an individual may have, but he seeks the right to carry on a trade or business in the municipal market.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit