Nebraska Supreme Court June 13, 1936, No. 29781 (Helfrich v. Baxter)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-06-1936
Day, J.
In this suit to foreclose a mortgage after the sale of the mortgaged premises, the plaintiff sought a judgment against the defendants involved in this appeal for the resulting deficiency on the mortgage debt in the sum of approximately $13,000. In 1919 Elwood executed a note, due in five years, and secured- it by this real estate mortgage. Helfrich bought the note and mortgage in 1923. The defendants and others purchased the property after the execution of the mortgage and took title in Baxter as trustee. They did not assume and agree to pay the mortgage debt. Payment of the note and mortgage was extended five years in 1923. For a more comprehensive statement of facts, see Helfrich v. Baxter, 128 Neb. 281, 258 N. W. 532, an opinion on a former appeal of this same case. It was determined by this court at that time: (1) That grantee’s retention of the amount of the mortgage out of the purchase price does not render him personally liable for the mortgage debt in the absence of an agreement to pay it; (2) that section 20-2141, Comp. St. 1929, as amended by section 1, ch. 41, Laws 1933, taking away the power of the court to enter deficiency judgments was not applicable to this, a suit pending at the time the statute became effective; (3) that there was a valuable consideration for the contract between Helfrich and the *287appellees for the contract of January 5, 1928; and (4) that the court has the power to award a deficiency judgment. The cause was remanded for a new trial in accordance with the opinion and not with directions to enter a judgment.
The decision of the supreme court upon a former appeal becomes the law of the case only as to the actual question then determined. Schwanenfeldt v. Chicago, B. & Q. R. Co., 80 Neb. 790, 115 N. W. 285.
The only defendants involved in this appeal are Reynolds, A. Herzberg, and Calkins. They did not hold the legal title and are not liable for a deficiency on the mortgage unless by an agreement to pay the same.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit