Supreme Court of the United States March 29, 1937, 340 (Dugas v. American Surety Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-03-1937

Mr. Justice Van Devanter,

after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the Court.

1. The amount or penalty of the qualifying bond was $20,000.00. The surety’s obligation was not to Dugas alone, but to the other claimants as well; and this obligation was not to pay all claims regardless of their aggregate, but to pay $20,000.00, or so much thereof as should be needed, and no more. Because the claims exceeded $20,000.00, the surety paid that sum into the registry of the federal court, there to abide the court’s decree, and at the same time brought in that court its interpleader suit against all claimants, including Dugas, to the end that its liability on the bond might be terminated, and that the rights of the several claimants in the amount of the bond so paid into court might be judicially determined and the fund distributed accordingly.

2. The Interpleader Act of 1926, under which that suit was brought, makes provision for the filing in á federal district court of a bill of interpleader by a surety company which has executed a bond in the sum of $500.00 or more, under which two or more claimants, citizens of different States, assert adverse rights to the penalty; authorizes the payment of the amount of the bond into the registry of the court, there to await such disposal as the court may direct; and further provides in the latter part of § 2 and in § 3:

“Sec. 2. . . . Notwithstanding any provision of the Judicial Code to the contrary, said court shall have power

*424

to issue its process for all such claimants and to issue an order of injunction against each of them, enjoining them from instituting or prosecuting any suit or proceeding in any State court or in any other Federal court ... on such bond . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.