Superior Court of Pennsylvania October 27, 1937, Appeal, 189 (Lloyd v. Kelly)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-1937

Opinion by

Cunningham, J.,

When this case came on for trial in the court below the pleadings, consisting of an amended statement of claim and an amended affidavit of defense which included new matter in the nature of a set-off and counterclaim, presented a rather complicated situation. At the conclusion of the testimony, however, the only matter actually in controversy was whether the plaintiff was entitled to appropriate to his own use (as a for

*33

feiture for the alleged breach by the defendant of certain contracts) the sum of $3,531.50, deposited with him by the defendant, or whether the defendant was entitled to take credit for this amount in the settlement of their mutual accounts. That issue arose out of the following circumstances.

J. R. Lloyd, the plaintiff, is a wholesale dealer at Pittsburgh in butter, eggs, cheese and “cold packed, selected, fruits and berries,” and Herbert W. Kelly, the defendant, is a retail dealer having his place of business in Altoona where he owns, or at least controls, a cold storage warehouse.

Lloyd had for sale and distribution, inter alia, a certain brand of cold packed fruits and berries known as the “Jarel Brand,”— a trade name owned by him. In January, 1930, the parties entered into negotiations looking toward the sale by defendant in Altoona and vicinity of that brand of fruits and berries. These negotiations resulted in the execution on January 28, 1930, of a contract, which may be considered as a “franchise,” granting to defendant the exclusive right to sell Jarel Brand fruits at retail in the designated territory. In this agreement, the term of which was two years from May 1, 1930, the plaintiff was designated as the seller and the defendant as the buyer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.