Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas April 7, 1937, No. 18983 (Harvey v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-04-1937
HAWKINS, Judge.
— Conviction was for passing a forged instrument, punishment assessed being two years in the penitentiary.
There was only one count in the indictment. It charged that appellant knowingly passed as true to Quincy Wilson a check dated June 25, 1936, drawn on the First National Bank & Trust Company of Tulsa, Oklahoma, in favor of Thomas McNeal, for $36.50, purporting to have been executed by the Marathon Oil Company, by Ralph P. Hyatt, it being stated in the body of the check that it was for services rendered by McNeal to the company in question.
Wilson testified that appellant came into his place of business about June 29th, 1936, and purchased a watch, in payment for which she tendered the check in question. Wilson made *215some inquiry about what bank the company did business with in Vernon and upon being told that it was the Herring National Bank he turned to telephone the bank, when appellant left the store. Wilson had not delivered the watch to áppellant and had not accepted the check in payment therefor. He says: “I did not give her any money and did not give her any watch; she turned around and walked out while I was phoning.”
The uncontradicted evidence shows that if appellant was guilty of anything she was guilty of the offense of attempting to pass the instrument in question to Wilson, but was not guilty of passing the same. See Smiley v. State, 80 Texas Crim. Rep., 280, 189 S. W., 482; McConnell v. State, 85 Texas Crim. Rep., 409, 212 S. W., 498; Houston v. State, 59 Texas Crim. Rep., 505, 128 S. W., 618.
In view of the uncontradicted evidence we are at some loss to understand why this case should ever have reached this court. It should have been disposed of by a peremptory instruction to acquit appellant upon the charge of passing a forged instrument.
Appellant excepted to the charge of the court for a failure to instruct the jury upon the law of circumstantial evidence. We quote from Mixon v. State, 90 S. W.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit