Court of Customs and Patent Appeals June 21, 1937, No. 3825 (In re Ferris)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-06-1937
BlaNd, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court:
The Primary Examiner of the United States Patent Office rejected all the appealed claims in the appellant’s application for the reissue of a patent No. 1,788,569 of January 13, 1931, relating to refining viscous mineral oils. The first eighteen claims of the patent stand allowed in the application. Upon appeal to the Board of Appeals, *1304the decision of the examiner was affirmed upon substantially the same grounds as those assigned by the examiner. From the decision of the board, appellant has here appealed.
The invention which is covered by the patent involves the use of aromatic nitro compounds as a selective solvent in the treatment of lubricating oils to produce fractions which differ therefrom in character in that one fraction is more paraffinic and the other more naphthenic than the original oil. Each of the patent claims calls for the use of nitrobenzene as a solvent but the specification of the patent states that this term is employed in a generic sense to include that material and equivalent aromatic nitro compounds or mixtures of them.
The purpose of the invention disclosed in the patent and of the invention which appellant claims in the appealed rejected claims is to obtain from an Appalachian crude oil and crude oils of the mixed base type from the mid-continent area an oil which may normally be obtained from the naphthenic oils from the Gulf Coast area. The claims also call for the production of an oil such as is normally obtained by distillation of Pennsylvania crudes. The original patent can hardly be said to teach that a paraffinic oil such as can be obtained from Pennsylvania oil may be obtained by the process recited.
Claims 19 to 37 were rejected by the tribunals as being broader than the disclostire in the patent since the rejected claims call for the use of a solvent broadly and are not limited to the use of aromatic nitro compounds.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit