District Court, S.D. Ohio August 4, 1937, No. 928 (Remington Rand, Inc. v. Acme Card System Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-08-1937

NEVIN, District Judge.

This is a patent suit brought in the usual form in which plaintiff, Remington Rand, Inc., a Delaware Corporation, claims that the defendants have infringed two United States Letters Patent owned by plaintiff. The Letters Patent in question are No. 1,407,948, issued February 28, 1922 (application filed February 13, 1920) to Benjamin G. Rand, and No. 1,429,628, issued September 19, 1922 (application filed August 9, 1920 — Amendment inserting certain specifications and Claim 20, filed March 31, 1922) to James H. Rand, Jr. Plaintiff prays for an injunction and an accounting.

Defendants are the Acme Card System Company, an Illinois Corporation, and Le Roy A. Franklin, of Cincinnati, Ohio. Mr. Franklin is the agent of the Acme Company in Cincinnati, where he has sold Acme cabinets of the kind charged to infringe both patents in suit.

Jurisdiction of the court over the subject matter and over both defendants is admitted. Plaintiff’s title to the patents in suit also is admitted by stipulation. The claims of the patent on which plaintiff relies are claims 1 and 11 of the Benjamin G. Rand patent No. 1,407,948 and claim 20 of James H. Rand, Jr., patent No. 1,-429,628.

Plaintiff filed its bill on July 3, 1935. On December 19, 1935, defendants filed their answer. In their answer defendants deny infringement of either patent, and aver that Letters Patent No. 1,407,948 are invalid because the subject matter thereof is shown and described in certain United States and foreign patents, which are set forth in the answer, and that patent No. 1,429,628 likewise is invalid because the subject matter thereof is shown and described in certain United States and foreign patents, which are set forth in the answer.

Defendants further allege that the disclosure shown and claimed in patent No. 1,407,948, is not the sole invention of Benjamin G. Rand and that the disclosure shown and claimed in the patent to James H. Rand, Jr., No.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.