Hawaii Supreme Court October 20, 1938, No. 2338. (Medeiros v. Udell)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-1938

*633

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

PETERS, J.

This is an action on a case for personal injuries. Verdict was for the defendant. Plaintiff’s exceptions present for review the denial by the trial court of his motion for a new trial upon the following grounds: 1. that the court erred in allowing the jury to continue their deliberations after they had requested that the reporter read certain of the testimony of the plaintiff, which request was not complied with due to the absence of the reporter; 2. that the jury were guilty of misconduct in their deliberations in that, against the specific instructions of the court, they conducted an experiment which was prejudicial to the plaintiff and which experiment and its result were considered by the jury in reaching their verdict. The alleged misconduct of the jury was not called to the attention of the trial court prior to verdict and then only upon the filing of the motion for a new trial.

This court of its own motion raised the preliminary question of whether it should consider the alleged error involving misconduct of the jury, the movant having failed to show affirmatively by his motion for a new trial or otherwise that the alleged misconduct was not known to the defendant’s counsel before verdict.

The occasion of the alleged misconduct was a view by the jury of the

locus in quo.

Neither the trial judge nor counsel were present, the jury being in the custody of the

*634

clerk under instructions of the court. The trial of the case had been concluded and the cause submitted to the jury. The jury had been taken to lunch at 12:03 p.m. and after lunch repaired to the scene of the accident. After view the jury were returned to the courthouse and retired to consider their verdict. The exact time at which the jury returned from the view does not appear. But the clerk’s minutes admit of the inference that it was about 2:30 p.m. The verdict was returned the same day at 8:30 p.m.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.