Utah Supreme Court March 18, 1938, No. 5961. (Holman v. Holman)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-03-1938

WOLFE, Justice.

Appeal from a judgment granting plaintiff a divorce on the ground of willful neglect to provide for the common necessaries of life. Defendant counterclaimed by amendment for divorce on the grounds of cruelty. The couple were married on September 18, 1930. Plaintiff was then 18 years of age. They have one child, a girl now over 5 years of age. Appellant raised by the assignment of errors ten questions. We will consider only one. Does the evidence show a willful failure to provide? We think it not only does not show a willful failure to provide, but does not show a failure to provide according to the standard required by the condition and social rank of the parties. It is true she did not receive all the clothes that she could have used and was forced to wear her dresses and coats longer than her pride would have liked, but he was out of work during 1932 and 1933. He made a little over $200' in 1934, more than $300 in 1935, and more than $400 in 1936. They lived

*302

since marriage at his father’s house. It had seven rooms. The father owned 54 acres of land, part of which was irrigated by rented water. He also owned a house and three lots in Fountain Green. They raised their own vegetables and fruit. They were plentifully supplied with milk, eggs, and butter. For a number of months in 1934, 1935, and 1936, she sold excess milk and butter, making, as she testified, $51 from that source. Her father-in-law calculated it to be $135 in 1935 and 1936, and $36 before 1935. She testifies to having personally saved, doing various jobs, $67.50. She said she spent on herself, on the child, and on the house, stove, and washing machine a total of $125.05. Her own figures show that unless she received money from her husband, or had some of the purchases charged which he paid, that she made at least $57.55 from selling milk and butter. She thought it was $51. But all this milk and butter came from cows either owned by the father-in-law or donated by him.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.