Ohio Court of Appeals April 15, 1938, No 2451 (Scharrer v. Ranz)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1938

OPINION

By BENNETT, J.

On May 24, 1932, the parents of the Appellee, Michael J. Scharrer, deeded to him several parcels of land by a deed which contained a clause, reading as follows:

“As a part of the consideration for this conveyance the said Michael J. Scharrer agrees to care for and provide all necessary 'food, clothing, shelter and medical attention for Michael Scharrer and Theresa Scharrer and their daughter, Mary Schariei.”

The named beneficiaries were appellee’s parents, the grantors, and their daughter, Mary Scharrer, who was, of course, the appellee’s sister.

Dr. Ranz filed a statement of claim against Michael J. Scharrer in the Municipal Court of Youngstown, in which he alleged that he had performed a necessary operation upon Mary Scharrer on September 9, 1935, that prior to the operation Mary and her mother had “made Known to him the contents” of this deed, that he performed the operation in reliance upon the obligation in said deed, that he charged Michael J. Scharrer the sum of $175.00 for the operation, that said amount was a reasonable charge for the services rendered, and that he accordingly asked for judgment against Michael J. Scharrer in the amount of $175.00.

The Municipal Court overruled a demurrer to the Statement of Claim and, the defendant not desiring to plead further, judgment was entered for the amount prayed for. The Common Pleas Court reversed the ruling, remanded the case, and instructed the Municipal Court to sustain the demurrer.

From that decision Dr. Ranz has appealed to this court on questions of law.

The judgment of the Common Pleas Court must be sustained. Dr. Ranz was not a party to the contract. To give a so-called “third party beneficiary” a right to sue on the contract it must appear that the contract was made directly or primarily for his benefit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.