District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania March 11, 1938, No. 1648 (United States v. Miller)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-03-1938
JOHNSON, District Judge.
This is a petition to suppress evidence obtained against petitioner during his arrest on a charge of unlawfully receiving and possessing lottery tickets, part of an interstate shipment.
The testimony shows that an agent of the Fedéral Bureau of Investigation received information that a shipment of lottery tickets had been sent from Herkhimer, N. Y., to W. J. Miller, 937 S. Queen street, York, Pa.,- bearing a return address of J. H. Morgan, Herkhimer, N. Y.; that on October 9, 1937, «the agent saw two -packages bearing the address as stated above, after they arrived at York by Railway Express, and was advised that they would be delivered to the home of the addressee; that after the packages had been.delivered, the agent went to Miller’s home and was advised by Miller’s daughter that Miller would return home between 11 and-12 p. m. that night; that at Miller’s home the agent saw the two packages in the hall oi Miller’s home; that the agent then procured a warrant for the arrest of Miller, awaited his return, went *543into the house with Miller and placed him under arrest; that the agent seized the two packages in the hall and made a search of the premises; and that the agent had no search warrant.
The petitioner contends that the search and seizure without a search warrant was in violation of his constitutional rights and the evidence obtained thereby should be suppressed. The government contends that the search and seizure was proper, being made as an incident to a lawful arrest and for instrumentalities of the crime.
In Lawson v. United States, 7 Cir., 9 F.2d 746, 748, it is stated: “All searches and seizures are not prohibited by the Constitution, and the two most common and well-recognized instances where seizures may be justified without a search warrant, are: (A) Where a person is lawfully arrested, he and the place where the arrest is made may be searched contemporaneously with the arrest. Carrol v. United States [267 U.S. 132, 43 S.Ct.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit