District Court, D. Massachusetts March 25, 1938, No. 705 (The Thor)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-03-1938
SWEENEY, District Judge.
This is a libel in admiralty in which the libelant seeks to recover for injuries to its barge Keystone No. 1, resulting from a collision between the barge and a mud scow being towed by the tug E. C. Dempsey.
Statements of fact herein are intended as findings of fact, and statements of legal conclusions, as rulings of law, in accordance with Admiralty Rule 46½, 28 U.S.C.A. following section 723.
The facts are as follows: On April 21, 1936, the barge Keystone No. 1 was being towed by the tug Thor (then named Nathaniel P. Doane). As it approached the eastern end of the Cape Cod Canal, en route to Tiverton, R. I., the tug Thor changed the barge tie-up from a long hawser to a short hawser running from the stern of the tug to a wire bridle fastened on the front of the bargk. There was about 50 feet of open water between the stern of the tug and the forward end of the barge as they proceeded through the canal.
Having passed without incident through the length of the canal, the tug Thor proceeded around Hunnewell’s Point, and thence directly towards buoy No. 21, keeping dose to her right-hand side of the channel. At about the time that the tug Thor made the turn at ITunnewell’s Point, it observed the tug E. C. Dempsey, which had hooked up along its port side mud scow No. 52 which it was towing towards the westerly entrance of the canal, which means that it was going in a direction opposite to that of the tug Thor. The mud scow, which the E. C. Dempsey had in tow, was fastened along its port side so that the forward end of the mud scow projected about 100 feet beyond the bow of the tug E. C. Dempsey. They were holding to their right-hand side of the channel which at the point of collision was about 250 feet wide.
The master of the tug Thor observed, just prior to reaching a point opposite buoy 21, that his barge was following directly in line with the Thor, both of which were well over toward their own side of the channel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit