District Court, S.D. New York June 30, 1938 (Dominick v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-1938

CLANCY, District Judge.

The plaintiff was one of the owners in fee of certain premises with the buildings thereon in New York City, and on November 12, 1925 they leased the premises by written instrument for a term of twenty-one years beginning November 15, 1925 with a conditional option of a renewal for a. like term. Upon default by lessee, the landlords repossessed the premises on February 23, 1934. Between those dates the tenant had installed permanent and substantial alterations, some apparently structural and none removable from the structure, of which they became part, nor subject to separate disposition. They became part of the realty before repossession. Since repossession, the premises have been rented for the same business purposes for which they were altered.

In March, 1935, plaintiff filed his income tax return for the year 1934 in which he included the sum of $4,809.29 as his pro rata share of the value of the improvements made by the lessee while lessee. He later claimed refund of the amount paid as tax on such sum, the claim was rejected and finally disallowed and this suit followed.

Plaintiff moves for summary judgment and the defendant moves to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a cause of action. Plaintiff bases his motion on the decision of our Circuit Court of Appeals in Hewitt Realty Co. v. Commissioner, 2 Cir., 76 F.2d 880, 98 A.L.R. 1201, and that of the Ninth Circuit in Miller v. Gearin, 258 F. 225. The lessee in the Hewitt Case was yet in possession. While that decision does not determine the landlord’s liability for income tax after the lease terminates, some of its language seems to say that the lessor’s gain can be computed only when realized by sale. The government’s position is that whatever gain is his is realized when the lessor regains possession. The gain accrued to his capital when the tenant added to it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.