District Court, S.D. Ohio October 8, 1938, No. 963 (Stowe-Woodward, Inc. v. Cincinnati Rubber Mfg. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-1938

DRUFFEL, District Judge.

This is a suit for infringement of reissue letters patent No. 18,111, reissued June 29, 1931, to Stowe-Woodward Company but now owned by plaintiff. The bill seeks an injunction against defendant and prays for an accounting.

The defendant, on its part, denies infringement and challenges the validity of the patent on the following grounds : Nonconformity of law relating to reissue patents, laches relating to its disclaimer, anticipation, aggregation, lack of novelty, and invention.

The patent under consideration relates' to paper machine rolls for use in top press position, said.roll consisting of fragments of granite, sand, gravel, or quartz, etc., in a binder of hard rubber mounted on a metallic core.

It was the contention. of plaintiff and its evidence disclosed that in the art of papermaking on the modern papermaking machine the first stage is the mixture of the stock of pulp fibre, chemicals and water at what is known as the wet end of the machine. At this point the stock comprises about 99% water. From there it flows onto a vibrating wire screen, which has. the effect of draining the water and felting or putting together the tiny cellulose fibres into what is known as a wet web. The web moves along on the screen until it is picked up and deposited on a moving felt belt which also acts as a blotter to blot out more water. The second stage in the manufacture, and described as the most critical, is where the moving felt belt carrying the wet web of cellulose fibres passes through *57the first set of press rolls. The web at that point comprises about 85% water and 15% fibres. As the felt belt passes between the rolls the top press roll comes in direct contact with the wet web, the function of the top press roll being to press the water from the web and to consolidate the web into a compact sheet of paper. The shpet then continues to the second press rolls to the smoothing press, drying press, etc., to the finished sheet.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.