Appellate Court of Illinois June 6, 1938 (Jones v. Standerfer)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-06-1938
Mr. Justice Murphy
delivered the opinion of the court.
Lola Jones brought this action to recover damages for personal injuries she claimed to have sustained when struck by a truck. She made Lester Standerfer and the Mt. Vernon Home Oil Company herein referred to as the Oil Company, parties defendant. A trial by jury resulted in a verdict and judgment for $5,000 against both defendants. Defendants have perfected separate appeals and filed separate briefs. Some of the errors urged for reversal are common to both defendants but the Oil Company urges a ground not raised by Standerfer which we shall first discuss.
The Oil Company contends that there is no evidence tending to prove that George Standerfer, driver of the truck, was its servant. It contends that the relationship of the driver of the truck to it, can only be traced througli the contractual relationship existing between it and the defendant, Lester Standerfer, and asserts that Lester Standerfer was an independent contraetor.
The complaint on which the case was submitted to the jury consisted of four counts, each of which alleged that on the date of the accident the defendants, Lester Standerfer, and the Oil Company were engaged in the business of sale and distribution of gasoline and oil products within the city of Mt. "Vernon and were using a tank truck in the distribution of the same and that the defendants had in their employ as driver of the truck one George Standerfer.
The evidence conclusively shows that the truck was owned by defendant, Lester Standerfer, that he employed the driver, paid him his compensation and directed him as to his duties in reference to the sale of the products and collection of the same. It appears that his duties included the delivery of oil products to urban customers, that he used the truck-in making such deliveries, collected from the customers to whom he sold and made his reports to the defendant, Lester Standerfer.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit