Supreme Court of the United States December 4, 1939, 34 (Estate of Sanford v. Commissioner)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-12-1939
Mr. Justice Stone
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This and its companion case,
Rasquin
v.
Humphreys, post,
p. 54, present the single question of statutory construction whether in the case of an
inter vivos
transfer of property in trust, by a donor reserving to himself the
*41
power to designate new beneficiaries other than himself, the gift becomes complete and subject to the gift tax imposed by the federal revenue laws at the time of the relinquishment of the power. Corelative questions, important only if a negative answer is given to the first one, are whether the gift becomes complete and taxable when the trust is created or, in the case where the donor has reserved a power of revocation for his own benefit and has relinquished it before relinquishing the power to change beneficiaries, whether the gift first becomes complete-and taxable at the time of relinquishing the power of revocation.
In 1913, before the enactment of the first gift tax statute of 1924, decedent created a trust of personal property for the benefit of named beneficiaries, reserving to himself the power to terminate the trust in whole or in part, or to modify it. In 1919 he surrendered the power to revoke the trust by an appropriate writing in which he reserved “the right to modify any or all of the trusts” but provided that this right “shall in no way be deemed or construed to include any right or privilege” in the donor “to withdraw principal or income from any trust.” In August, 1924, after the effective date of the gift tax statute, decedent renounced his remaining power to modify the trust. After hjs death in 1928, the Commissioner following the decision in
Hesslein
v.
Hoey,
91 F. 2d 954, in 1937, ruled that the gift became complete and taxable only upon decedent’s final renunciation of his* power to modify the trusts and gave notice of a tax deficiency accordingly.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit