Ohio Supreme Court December 13, 1939, No. 27765 (State, Ex Rel. v. Indus. Comm.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-12-1939

The issue raised by the demurrer to the petition is whether the Industrial Commission had jurisdiction to consider the application for reconsideration filed by claimant Harold McDonnell on May 4, 1939. It is conceded in the instant case that more than ten years had elapsed since the disability is alleged to have begun and that no compensation had been awarded by the commission during such period. The limitation clause in Section 1465-86, General Code, reads in part as follows: "* * * ten years after the injury in cases in which no compensation ever has been awarded." If this limitation in Section 1465-86, General Code, has been incorporated by reference into the occupational disease statute, Section 1465-68b, General Code, then the demurrer to the petition must be overruled. In order to determine the question presented, it becomes necessary to consider the purpose of the workmen's compensation statutes in their entirety. The General Assembly, in 1921 for the first time, by Section 1465-68a, General Code, provided for compensation for some occupational diseases in the Workmen's Compensation Law of Ohio (109 Ohio Laws, 183). At the same time it enacted Section 1465-68b, General Code, which has remained unchanged ever since (109 Ohio Laws, 185, effective August 5, 1921). Prior thereto the Workmen's Compensation Act, as amended in 1913 (103 Ohio Laws, 72), contained numerous provisions for the administration of the law, payment of claims and other administrative matters. One section provided for the rate of compensation in cases of temporary disability, another for the rate of compensation in cases of partial disability, and still another for the *Page 151 amount of compensation in cases of permanent or total disability. Section 1465-82, General Code, provided for the amount of death benefits and Section 1465-84, General Code, set forth the basis upon which such benefits were to be computed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.