California Court of Appeal November 8, 1939, Civ. No. 11015 (Kerr Gifford & Co. v. American Distilling Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-11-1939

STURTEVANT, J.

In this action the plaintiff sued to recover an alleged balance claimed to be due on the sale of a quantity of corn. The trial court made findings in favor of the defendant and from a judgment entered thereon the plaintiff has appealed.

In its complaint the plaintiff alleged: “That on or about July 14, 1937, plaintiff agreed to sell to defendant and defendant agreed to purchase from plaintiff 500 short tons of 2,000 lbs. each of Argentine corn in bulk, to be of fair aver*392age quality, 1937 crop, for a price of $2.02% per 100 lbs, f. o. b. ears Oakland elevator, Oakland, California, shipment from elevator as instructed by buyer, 10 days free storage after arrival and 15^ per ton per month storage to be paid to defendant on any undelivered portion thereafter. ’ ’ The defendant denied the foregoing allegations and pleaded affirmatively certain new matter.

The plaintiff contends that all findings predicated on the existence of any terms of sale or agreement, other than alleged in its complaint and as set forth above, are contrary to the evidence. On the trial it produced a document in words and figures as follows:

“Kerr Gifford & Co. Inc.

San Francisco, California July 14, 1937. No. 51.

The American Distilling Company 369 Pine Street

San Francisco, California.

Gentlemen:

We confirm sale of the following to you:

Quantity Five hundred (500) tons of 2000 lbs. Commodity Argentine corn — f. a. q. (bulk) 1937 crop.

Price $2.02% per cental — net cash against bills of

lading and weight certificates.

Basis f. o. b. cars Oakland Elevator, Oakland, Cali-

fornia. (shipment from Elevator as instructed by buyer)

Shipment S. S. ‘West Cactus’ or substitute — July 1937 shipment from the Argentine.

Remarks Ten days free storage after arrival — 15(5 per ton per month on undelivered portion thereafter.

(Signed) Kerr Gifford & Co., Inc., by W. S. Bell. Accepted by S. McTigue.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.