City of New York Municipal Court April 27, 1939 (Edelstein v. Oxman)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1939

Wendel, Ch. J.

Motions No. 31 and No. 32 of April 18, 1939, are consolidated.

It seems that the confession of judgment in favor of Nathan Rubin -was filed with the clerk of the Bronx Municipal Court, Second District, on March 15, 1939, but it was not entered by the clerk on that date due to some inadvertence. A judgment should be considered entered as of the date all papers in proper form were submitted to the clerk, and the proper fee paid. Therefore, *553it is proper to consider the Rubin judgment entered as of March 15, 1939, and an order has, in fact, been made by a justice of the Municipal Court directing its entry nunc pro tunc as of March 15, 1939. I have come to the conclusion, therefore, that the Rubin judgment takes precedence. The Rubin supplementary proceeding was the first to be instituted and the third party is, therefore, directed to pay to the said judgment creditor Rubin the sum of $282.17. It must be considered that the fund in the possession of the third party is held by him for the debtor. (Miller v. Clayton Coffee Pot, Inc., 238 App. Div. 121.) As payment to the creditor Rubin exhausts the fund the application of the creditors Edelstein and others is denied.

Settle order on notice to all respondents.

On reargument, May 26, 1939.

Motion for reargument is granted. Upon reargument the original determination is adhered to.

The court is not troubled by the failure of the clerk to sign the judgment. That is merely “ a clerical misprision ” (Freeman on Judgments, infra) which did not affect the judgment creditor’s rights or remedies. The justice of the Municipal Court properly allowed the judgment to be signed by the clerk nunc pro tunc and in that connection full effect should be given to the order of that justice. (See Van Alstyne v. Cook, 25 N. Y. 489; Lythgoe v. Lythgoe, 75 Hun, 147, 151; affd., 145 N. Y. 641; 1 Freeman on Judgments [5th ed.], § 148, and cases cited in footnotes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.