District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania March 6, 1940, 494 (Kraft v. Cohen)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-1940

KALODNER, District Judge.

This is a copyright infringement suit, tried before me without a jury. Plaintiff seeks an injunction, statutory damages and damages under the Common Law.

Plaintiff is engaged in the business of printing and distributing bound books containing illustrations depicting clothing in various styles and of various sorts, including clerical vestures. The plaintiff does not sell clothing. He derives his income by selling his books to firms which do sell clothing. The books are used by the clothing firms to show to prospective customers, and, therefore, constitute media whereby the clothing firms can. show styles of garments to such prospective customers without displaying the garments themselves.

The defendants are outfitters specializing in clerical vestments. As an adjunct to their business, they issue catalogues illustrating their merchandise, including the vestments.

In March, 1938, one Brady, an employee of the plaintiff, called on Cohen, one of the defendant firm. Brady had with him five photographs, picturing men wearing clerical vestments. These photographs had been made from original drawings composed by the plaintiff. The drawings were left with Cohen. The purpose for which they were left is disputed between the parties, as I shall presently explain.

On or about the 6th day of September, 1938, the defendants issued a printed catalogue called “National Vestments for Clergy and Choir”. The book contained pictures of men dressed in various styles of the clothing, and among the illustrations were the five represented by the photographs left by Brady with Cohen.

On April 15, 1938, the plaintiff published a book which it entitled “Newest Style Portfolio, Autumn 1938-1939, Winter”. On this book a copyright application was filed on May 17, 1938, and the copyright registration was issued thereon on May 17,1938.

On May 10, 1938, plaintiff published a book entitled “Special Clerical Brochure Featuring Authentic Apparel for Clergymen.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.