New York Court of Appeals December 31, 1940 (Matter of Hilsenrad v. Miller)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-1940

Lewis, J.

Our inquiry goes to the question whether by employment for ten months in the State civil service, all of which was under a temporary appointment, the petitioner

*448

gained the legal status of a permanent civil service employee. The material facts are not in controversy.

The petitioner passed a civil service examination for the position of law case investigator in the Department -of Labor. His rating qualified him as No. 5 on the eligible list promulgated for that position. While awaiting appointment the petitioner and all others on the newly-created eligible list received from the State Industrial Commissioner a letter which read in part: “ Would you accept, if offered,

temporary appointment

as Labor Welfare Investigator for a period of from one to five months with possibility of permanency at a salary of $1,700 per annum in our Albany office?” (Emphasis supplied.)

After declination, or failure to respond, by all those who qualified above the petitioner on the eligible list, the petitioner accepted the offer and promptly received from the Industrial Commissioner a written communication that he

“

* * * had been selected for appointment to the position of Labor Welfare Investigator in this Department, at a salary of $1,700 per annum, for a

temporary

period from one to five months with possibility of permanency, effective Tuesday, March first, 1938.”

The petitioner served under such appointment from March 1 to July 31, 1938, and, upon the request of the Industrial Commissioner, was continued

“

on a temporary basis ” for a period of one month until September 1, 1938.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.