Supreme Court of the United States March 3, 1941, 344 (Conway v. O'Brien)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-03-1941
*493
Mr. Justice Reed
delivered the opinion, of the Court.
Petitioner, a citizen of New Hampshire, was injured when the respondent’s car, in which she was a passenger, collided with another on a country road in Vermont. Diversity of citizenship gave jurisdiction to the District Court and petitioner recovered a verdict under the Vermont guest occupant law,
1
which required her to prove gross negligence on the part of the respondent. The Circuit Court of Appeals, however, considering the evidence of gross negligence insufficient to go to the jury, reversed and dismissed the complaint.
2
We granted certiorari to examine whether there had been sufficient compliance with Rule 50 (b) to authorize dismissal of the complaint,
3
but our view of the merits makes it unnecessary to discuss this question.
The result is determined by a consideration of the facts in the light of the Vermont law. The accident occurred in broad daylight in the late morning of an August day. If the facts most favorable to the petitioner were accepted, the jury might have concluded properly that the defendant’s car approached from the south a covered bridge on a little-used country road at a speed of fifteen miles per hour. Respondent who was the driver and owner sat on the front seat with another. The petitioner and another lady occupied the rear seat. The bridge spanned Williams River which at that point
*494
ran eastwardly to join the Connecticut. As another car emerged from its southern end the collision happened.
The road along which respondent was driving ran parallel with the southernly bank of the river for a short distance and then turned “abruptly,” in a “sharper curve than any on the road,” at a sixty degree angle down a nine per cent grade towards the bridge. Bushes and small trees cut off the view of a car “coming out of the bridge” until the respondent’s car was “probably 30 feet” away.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit