Supreme Court of the United States April 28, 1941, 627 (Helvering v. William Flaccus Oak Leather Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-04-1941
Mr. Justice Murphy
delivered the opinion of the Court.
In September, 1935, respondent’s plant was destroyed* by fire. Later that year it received $73,132.50 from an insurance company as compensation for the loss of buildings, machinery, and equipment. The buildings, machinery; and equipment had been fully depreciated for income tax purposes prior to 1935, and no part of the insurance proceeds was used to acquire other property similar or related in service or use to the property de-. stroyed, or to acquire control of a corporation owning such property, or to establish a fund to replace the property destroyed.
In its return for 1935, respondent reported the insurance proceeds as capital gain and added to that amount a gain, not in issue here, of $862.50 from sales of securities. During that same year, respondent had capital losses, also not in dispute, of $76,767.62 which it used to offset completely the total reported capital gains of $73,995. This left an excess of capital losses over capital gains of $2,772.62, and respondent deducted $2,000 of that amount from ordinary .income.
The Commissioner held that the insurance proceeds were ordinary income rather than capital gain. Accordingly, he decreased respondent’s capital gain and increased its ordinary income by $73,132.50, and allowed respondent capital losses of only $2,862.50, an amount equal to the gain from security sales plus $2,000. The Board of Tax Appeals affirmed in a memorandum opinion on the authority of Estate of Herder, 36 B. T. A. 934.
*249
The Circuit Court of Appeals reversed. 114 F. 2d 783. We granted certiorari, 312 U. S. 671, because, the decision below was in conflict with
Herder
v.
Helvering,
70 App. D. C. 287; 106 F. 2d 153.
It is conceded that respondent’s losses resulted from sales or exchanges of capital assets. It is also conceded that the entire amount received from the insurance company- must be ..
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit