Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit February 3, 1941, 7574 (Krafft v. Cohen)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-02-1941
GOODRICH, Circuit Judge.
This is an appeal from a judgment of the District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania awarding damages to the plaintiff for infringement of copyright by the defendants, and enjoining further infringement. The subject-matter of the litigation consists of three pictures of figures in clerical vestments. These pictures were originally brought by a representative of the plaintiff, who is a publisher of men’s fashions, to the defendants, who are manufacturers of various articles of wearing apparel. The pictures represented figures plothed in clerical vestments. How the pictures came to be left with the defendants and for what purpose, was a matter of dispute in the trial court, but that question is not before us since the litigation here turns solely upon the question of the validity of the copyright. The pictures were subsequently returned to the plaintiff.
On May 10, 1938 plaintiff printed a leaflet called, by the parties, a “Brochure” which contained, among others, the three illustrations left with the defendants. In the meantime, defendants had made reproductions of these three illustrations. The first copies of the Brochure were printed with the copyright notice on the back cover only and lacked the name of the proprietor. This notice was clearly defective because it did not comply with the statute.
1
Sometime subsequent to May 10, 1938 the plaintiff affixed a proper copyright notice to his Brochure.
On September 6, 1938 the defendants issued a catalogue which was called “National Vestments for Clergy and Choir”. They contained defendants’ reproductions of three of the plaintiff’s pictures. On September 19, 1938 the plaintiff’s attorney wrote to the defendants advising them of the plaintiff’s claim of copyright.
On January 25, 1939 the plaintiff filed an application for copyright on the “Brochure”, claiming the date of his first publication as May 10, 1938. A certificate of copyright registration was duly issued on.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit