Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit April 21, 1941, 7648 (Littell v. Evening Star Newspaper Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-04-1941

MILLER, Associate Justice.

Appellant applied for a position with appellee newspaper company and, after several conferences, was employed at a salary of $35 per week. This employment was temporary, for a period of four weeks, to give appellant an opportunity to see whether she could work out an advertising sales plan consisting of a marketing news advertising page. At the end of the four weeks appellant confessed that she had failed. Thereafter, she worked out some ideas for the improvement of the plan previously discussed and persuaded appellee to give her two weeks’ additional temporary employment further to test the feasibility of the plan. At the end of the two weeks she had' succeeded in selling the desired space; the new feature was adopted by the newspaper; and appellant was employed upon a “permanent” basis. She continued in the employ of appellee newspaper company for a number of years, during all of which time the advertising plan which she had worked out was continued , in use by appellee and, in fact, became a very profitable feature of the company’s Evening Star newspaper. Thereafter, appellant was discharged and paid four weeks’ salary in advance.

This action was commenced in the lower court on the theory, set out in appellant’s complaint, that she had entered into a contract with appellee calling for permanent

*37

employment, and that such employment could not be terminated at the will of appellee, as was done in the present case. Two questions are presented on appeal: (1) What elements are necessary in order to constitute a contract of permanent employment? (2) Are the, facts of the present case sufficient to prove that such a contract was made ?

The rule is that unless the parties reveal an intent to enter into a contract for permanent employment, it will be regarded as terminable.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.