Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit May 26, 1941, 278 (Burris v. American Chicle Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-05-1941
CHASE, Circuit Judge.
The plaintiff received bodily injuries •when he fell from a swinging scaffold while at work as an employee of Ashland Window & House Cleaning Company, Inc., in the performance of the lattet’s contract with the owner to clean the windows in a public building owned by the American Chicle Company in New York City. He sued the American Chicle Company and it in turn cited in the Ashland Company under a third party complaint upon the theory that it was bound to indemnify Chicle in so far as the latter was liable to the plaintiff. Jurisdiction rests upon diversity of citizenship. The trial was to a jury. As the case was submitted, the only count in the plaintiff’s complaint was based upon a violation of Sec. 202 of the New York Labor Law, Consol.Laws, c. 31, and the rules of the Industrial Board of the Department of - Labor of the State of New York promulgated thereunder. A verdict was returned for the plaintiff which was attacked by motion to set it aside as excessive and to grant a new trial. The granting of the motion was prevented by a stipulation by the plaintiff that judgment might be entered for a reduced amount. Judgment for such amount was then entered against American Chicle Company and judgment over in its favor against the Ash-land Company. All parties appealed.
There was ample, though on some material points disputed, evidence to enable tire jury to find as follows:
The plaintiff who had had some twelve years experience in the work was, just before he was hurt on October 14, 1937, on a swinging scaffold with another workman, named Moore, on the outside of a building owned by the American Chicle Company cleaning the windows from the outside. He was employed by the Ashland Window & House Cleaning Company, Inc., which furnished the scaffold and its equipment including the ropes by which it was held in place and raised or lowered.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit