Supreme Court of Alabama April 17, 1941, 8 Div. 61. (Johnson v. Maness)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-04-1941
FOSTER, Justice.
This is a second appeal, see 232 Ala. 411, 168 So. 452.
As considered on that appeal, complainant sought to enforce an alleged agreement made by defendant when complainant as mortgagor executed a deed in lieu of foreclosure, by which defendant agreed to allow complainant two years in which to redeem. This Court denied relief to complainant on that hearing because defendant alleged and proved that any such agreement, if made, was within the statute of frauds and void, on defendant’s plea to that effect. Defendant could have waived that defense and have stood on his denial of the making of such an agreement, if he had chosen to do so. That was pointed out on the former appeal.
*159
After the remandment, the bill was amended by adding a new theory of equitable right on the idea that the deed made in lieu of foreclosure was not valid; that there was not only the agreement to allow complainant two years in which to redeem, but, in addition, that the consideration was wholly inadequate: that complainant was an ignorant farmer unable to read and write, not familiar with business transactions, and being unable to pay the debt nor obtain a loan to refinance it, and in the very worst period of the depression (January 1933) he was overreached by a demand for payment and a promise to allow redemption, and thereby induced to make the deed; though he had paid more than half the debt and made improvements on the place; that respondent took advantage of his ignorance and necessitous circumstances by making a promise to allow redemption.
The claim thus made to set aside the deed and allow an exercise of the equity of redemption can be supported in equity on the facts alleged on two distinct equitable principles.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit