Supreme Court of Alabama May 29, 1941, 6 Div. 742. (Brown Hauling Co. v. Newsome)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1941

*302

GARDNER, Chief Justice.

Plaintiff’s car collided with defendant’s tiuck at the intersection of 24th Street and 36th Avenue in the City of Birmingham, inflicting injuries for which plaintiff recovered a judgment upon a complaint containing two counts, the first resting upon simple negligence and the second, wantonness. The refusal of the affirmative charge as to each count is assigned as error and argued in brief.

Likewise the denial of the motion for a new trial is assigned as error. These are the only questions here presented for decision.

The proof was ample to the effect that the driver of defendant’s truck entered the intersection, driving west on 36th Avenue and into 24th Street, in disobedience of the city ordinance requiring him to stop before so entering the intersection, and that the legible “stop sign” before him was ignored. Defendant’s insistence for the affirmative charge upon the simple negligence count is rested upon the theory plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence proximately contributing to the accident as a matter of law and is of consequence barred of recovery thereon, citing Britt v. Daniel, 230 Ala. 79, 159 So. 684; Greer v. Marriott, 27 Ala.App. 108, 167 So. 597, and Griffith Freight Lines v. Benson, 234 Ala. 613, 176 So. 370.

Defendant first insists plaintiff was guilty of negligence in admittedly failing to stop at the intersection as he entered 24th Street going south, as stipulated in Section 2, Ordinance 25 F of the City of Birmingham. But plaintiff’s evidence was to the efféct .there was not at that time and indeed had never been any sign of any character at that point. As a consequence, under the provision of our statute [Section 1397(102), Michiet Code 1928, Code 1940, Tit. 36, § 48], said ordinance was ineffective to constitute plaintiff a violator thereof.

Defendant next insists plaintiff was guilty of negligence in driving at a speed (in excess of 20 miles per hour) made prima facie unlawful by city ordinance.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.