Arizona Supreme Court June 16, 1941, Civil No. 4349. (Engle v. Scott)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-06-1941

lead-opinion

LOCKWOOD, C. J.

Roy R. Hislop, as city manager, and E. C. Moore, .as chief of police of the city of Phoenix, brought suit in the superior court of Maricopa county against J. F. Engle, Edward Rosengren, W. 0. Creamer and James Aaron, defendants, asking first that it be adjudged that defendant Engle, by and through his agents, employees or associates, was maintaining a public nuisance

per se

in the places described in the complaint, and that such nuisance is subject to summary abatement by plaintiffs under the ordinances of the city of Phoenix and the laws of the state of Arizona, and second, that each of the defendants and their agents be forever enjoined from keeping, occupying and maintaining horse race betting establishments of

*386

tlie character described in the complaint at any place within the jurisdiction of the court. The prayer for relief was based upon the allegations that defendants were operating and maintaining establishments “where persons daily congregated for the purpose of making bets and wagers on horse races run in other states, such betting being made under the pari mutuel system of betting, said pari mutuel machines being located at the various tracks where the races are run in states other than the State of Arizona; that persons did daily congregate in said room for the purpose of making bets and wagers on horse races run in other states, which bets defendant J. F. Engle and his agents, employees or associates accepted and received, and after said races were run paid to the winners, if any, the amounts won by such persons,” and that by so doing the defendants were maintaining a public nuisance

per se,

to-wit, a gaming house or place.

After the action was filed Hislop and Moore retired from their offices and Donald C. Scott and Lou Holtzendorff, their successors in office, were substituted as plaintiffs.

Defendants filed separate answers in which many defenses were raised.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.