Supreme Court of Colorado April 14, 1941, No. 14,724. (Riss & Co. v. Galloway)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-04-1941
Mr. Justice Young
delivered the opinion of the court.
The present litigation arose out of the same accident that gave rise to
Riss & Co. v. Anderson,
108 Colo. 78. 114 P. (2d) 278, the opinion in which was announced this day. The same stipulation as to defendant’s negligence proximately causing the injuries was entered into. Judgment was rendered for plaintiff in the present case on the verdict of a jury that assessed his damages at $6,850, and defendant, seeking a reversal, prosecutes a writ of error.
Certain of the points here raised we think are covered fully by our opinion in the other case, namely, (1) the defense sought to be interposed that the Mountain States Telephone and Telegraph Company benefit plan is in lieu of workmen’s compensation and that plaintiff’s acceptance of benefits thereunder precluded his bringing suit for his injuries; and (2) the excessiveness of the verdict.
*95
Certain other features of this case require consideration. The defendant has favored us with numerous assignments of error, to be exact, twenty-nine. In addition to those that raise points of which we disposed in our other opinion, defendant in its brief has grouped the remaining errors under five heads, namely, (1) Denial of defendant’s motion for an order requiring plaintiff to submit to a spinal puncture. (2) Overruling of defendant’s objection to a hypothetical question asked of Dr. Farley, one of plaintiff’s expert witnesses. (3) Denial of defendant’s motion to strike testimony of witness Farley and other evidence of back injuries sustained by plaintiff and to limit the question of damages. (4) Refusal to permit Doctors Baker and Woodbridge to testify when presented as witnesses by defendant. (5) Refusal of the court to give defendant’s tendered instructions 1, 4, 5, and 6, and the giving of instruction No. 12.
The plaintiff was a man forty-seven years of age.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit