Supreme Court of Florida February 4, 1941 (Henry L. Doherty Co., Inc. v. Joachim)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-02-1941
Thomas, J.
The chancellor denied a motion to- dismiss an amended bill of complaint brought by the trustees under the will of Samuel Barchard, deceased, against Henry L. Doherty & Company and Town of Palm Beach. The movants seek a review of his order.
By the allegations of the pleading it appears that the testator and his successors in title owned for many years property situated about three hundred feet west of the ocean boulevard extending along the surf bank. The driveway is not continuous through the town but is interrupted directly east of plaintiffs’ lot. For a distance of about seven-tenths of a mile there is a pathway, extending in the same general direction, utilized by pedestrians and cyclists, which connects this boulevard with one proceeding thence southward near the sea shore.
Thus a motorist traveling from north to south through Palm Beach and keeping as near the sea as possible would drive south to the intersection east of the land in question; turn westward by that property to a street parallel with the ocean, go southward seven-tenths of a mile; turn east to the other section of the boulevard and then, by turning to
*52
the right, resume his original course, while a cyclist could travel between the same points without detour.
The walkway appeared on a plat recorded in the official records of the county in 1920 and in approximately the same location has been used by the public for nineteen years.
Four years ago the defendant company acquired property east and west of that part of the walk located nearest plaintiff’s lot and thereafter the defendant town ordained that the pathway be vacated and discontinued, whereupon, the defendant company erected barricades across the easement at its north and south property lines.
The bill concludes with a description of the community and the relative positions of plaintiffs’ property and the religious, entertainment and commercial areas hard by.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit