Supreme Court of Georgia June 16, 1941, 13621. (Barbre v. Barbre)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-06-1941

Atkinson, Presiding Justice.

Ground 6 of the motion for new trial assigns error on the overruling of the objection to

*389

testimony of plaintiff’s witness, Mrs. J. C. Barbre, relating to transactions and communications with the deceased insured. It challenges the competency of the witness to give the testimony, the grounds of challenge being that she was testifying to conversations and transactions which she as agent for the petitioners had with a person now deceased. It is provided by statute that, where a suit is instituted or defended by an indorsee, assignee or transferee of a deceased or insane person, the opposite party shall not be competent to testify in his own favor as to transactions or communications with such insane or deceased person; and that the agent or attorney of the surviving or sane party shall not be allowed to testify in favor of such party under circumstances where the principal could not testify. Code, § 38-1603 (1, 5). It is clear that under this statute, if the defendant in the present ease is an indorsee, assignee, or transferee of Primus J: Barbre, deceased, the testimony objected to, both parties agreeing that she was the agent of petitioners, was inadmissible. In

Hendricks

v.

Allen,

128

Ga.

181 (2) (57 S. E. 224), it was said: “It was not competent for the plaintiff to testify as to a transaction between himself and one since deceased, the effect of which would be to impeach the right of the deceased to convey the property in controversy to another person, when such other person or his personal representative was a party defendant in the case.” In that case the legal representative of the deceased person was not a party to the suit,-nor was the estate of the deceased person otherwise involved. In

Hudson

v.

Broughton,

147

Ga.

547 (94 S. E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.