Supreme Court of Georgia November 11, 1941, 13771. (Harris v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-11-1941
1. In order to sustain a plea of former jeopardy, it is always incumbent upon the defendant to plead and prove that the transaction charged in the second indictment is the same as a matter of fact as that charged in the first indictment under which he was put in jeopardy. In addition to pleading and proving that the transaction is the same as a matter of fact, it is also necessary to plead and prove: either (a) that the transaction charged in the second indictment is an offense which is identical in law with that charged in the first indictment, or else that under the actual terms of the first indictment proof of the second offense was made necessary as an essential ingredient of the offense as first charged; or (b) that the transaction charged in the second indictment is an offense which represents either a major or minor grade of the same offense, of which the defendant might be convicted under an indictment for the major offense; or (c) where the transactions are the same as a matter of fact, even though the offenses be not identical or in effect identical as a matter of law, so as to come within the scope of the preceding subsections (a) or (b), he may nevertheless, under the principles of res judicata which may be included in a plea under the broader doctrine of former jeopardy, show that his acquittal on the first charge was necessarily controlled by the determination of some particular issue or issues of fact which would preclude his conviction of the second charge. 2. If the State, instead of demurring to a plea of former jeopardy, so as to give the allegations of fact a constructive verity (Lock v. State, 122 Ga. 730 (2), 50 S.E. 932; Burnam v. State, 2 Ga. App. 395, 396, 58 S.E. 683), files a traverse denying such allegations, the burden of proving them falls on the defendant; and unless the identity of the offenses as a matter of fact appears from the record of the two cases, it must be shown by other evidence. Sweeney v. State, 16 Ga. 467, 468; Gully v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit