Supreme Court of Georgia May 14, 1941, 13632. (Bankers Health & Life Insurance v. Crozier)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-1941

Jenkins, Justice.

Where no power of divestiture is reserved in a policy of life insurance, the issuance of the policy confers a vested right upon the person named therein as beneficiary, and the insured can not transfer such interest to any other person

*113

without the consent of such beneficiary.

Perry

v.

Tweedy,

128

Ga.

402 (57 S. E. 782, 119 Am. St. R. 393, 11 Ann. Cas. 46);

Smith

v.

Head,

75

Ga.

755;

Baldwin

v.

Wheat,

170

Ga.

449, 453 (153 S. E. 194). The rule is different, however, where a power to change the beneficiary or to assign the policy is reserved to the insured by the terms of the instrument; and in such a case the issuance of the policy does not confer a vested right or interest upon the beneficiary.

Hawkes

v.

Mobley,

174

Ga.

481, 483 (163 S. E. 494);

Washburn

v.

Washburn,

188

Ga.

468 (4 S. E. 2d, 35);

Farmers State Bank

v.

Kelley,

155

Ga.

733 (3), 737 (118 S. E. 197), and cit.;

Nally

v.

Nally,

74

Ga.

669, 674 (58 Am. R. 458);

Ogletree

v.

Ogletree,

127

Ga.

232 (2), 237 (55 S. E. 954). Accordingly, the first question propounded by the Court of Appeals must be answered in the negative.

A beneficiary named in a policy of life insurance acquires no vested right therein merely by virtue of paying the premiums, which, in the absence of any contractual obligation so to do, will be deemed gratuitous. 2 Couch’s Cyc. of Ins. Law, 1038, § 351, and cit.; 7 Cooley’s Briefs on Insurance, 6407, 6435, and cit. Accordingly, the second certified question must be answered in the negative.

In a policy of life insurance which reserves to the insured a right to change the beneficiary, the beneficiary by a mere payment of the premiums, without any valid contractual obligation so to do. would acquire no right to notice of an intended cancellation of the policy under an agreement between the insurer and the insured.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.