Supreme Court of Iowa March 11, 1941, No. 45570. (Heinz v. City of Davenport)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-03-1941

Miller,' J.

-Plaintiffs’ petition asserts that plaintiffs own certain real estate in Davenport, Iowa, which the defendant' City is undertaking to condemn for- the establishment' of an alley for a public use and purpose; that said undertaking violates section 18, Article I of the Constitution of Iowa in that it is in truth .and in fact the taking of plaintiffs’ property for a private use rather than for a public use, constitutes a legal fraud, is done in bad faith not for the public good but merely to aid and assist a private corporation with the powers belonging to defendant City. Plaintiff prayed for an injunction.

The answer asserts that the property was condemned for the establishment of an alleyway for a public use and purpose, denies that it was illegal, violative of the constitution, in bad faith to aid a private corporation, and asserts that the same was legal exercise of discretionary powers vested in the City. Defendant prayed that the action be dismissed.

The cause was tried upon an agreed statement of facts. The court dismissed the action at plaintiffs’ costs. Plaintiffs appeal.

The following facts were stipulated: For many years the Davenport Turn-Gemeinde, commonly known as the Turner So

*9

eiety, a social and fraternal organization with a large membership in the City of Davenport, has owned a plot of real estate at the southwest corner of Third and Scott Streets with a frontage of 150 feet on Third Street and 140 feet on Scott Street. There is a north and south paved alley 20 feet wide along the west side of said property but no east and west alley in the block. The Turner property is almost entirely covered by a large brick building, which was built about 1897, consisting of at least two principal units, the southern wall of said building being on the southern boundary line of the Turner property, except for a courtyard in the center of the southern part of the building. The west portion of the building is a theater, the other portion a club room.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.