Supreme Court of Louisiana May 26, 1941, No. 36178. (State v. Richey)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-05-1941

HIGGINS, Justice. •

The accused was originally indicted and tried for the murder of Bill Morgan. The case .resulted in a mistrial. The district

*92

attorney then filed a bill of information against the accused for manslaughter and on the trial thereof he was convicted and sentenced to not less than six nor more than eighteen years in the State Penitentiary. He has appealed and relies upon three bills of exception for the annullment of the verdict and sentence of the court.

The defendant and his family and the deceased and his family occupied a building which they jointly rented as a residence. It appears that, at the expiration of the lease, the defendant, without the knowledge of the deceased, rented the entire building for himself and his family only. The deceased remonstrated with the accused for having taken this action without informing him, and an argument ensued. The theory of the defense was that the defendant shot and killed the deceased while being attacked by the deceased and his son. The State undertook to show the jury that the accused killed the deceased, without any provocation whatsoever, while he was sitting on the front gallery reading a newspaper, and that after he was mortally wounded, in attempting to avoid the defendant, the deceased fell to the ground, whereupon, the accused fired the third and final shot into the back of his head.

Bill of exception No. 1 was reserved to the ruling of the trial judge in permitting the introduction by the State, in evidence, of the clothing worn by the deceased at the time of the homicide. Counsel for the defense state that, as there was no dispute as to the location of the wounds on the body of the deceased, there was no legal basis for the introduction of the garments in evidence and that this illegal evidence was highly prejudicial to their client because it inflamed the passion of the jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.