Louisiana Court of Appeal November 3, 1941, No. 17635. (Markel v. Walker)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-11-1941

The only question presented here is one of law. May a furnisher of materials obtain a personal judgment against an owner for the price of materials sold to the contractor and used in the building of the owner where there is a building contract, which was not recorded and the furnisher of materials did not file his claim in the office of the Recorder of Mortgages? Robert W. Markel is engaged in the sale of lumber and other materials used in the construction of buildings. Mr. and Mrs. James Bujol are the owners of the property, 2120 Annette Street, in New Orleans. They, desiring to make repairs, alterations and improvements, entered into a written contract with Ruffin J. Walker under which he undertook to do the work for $2,150, the said Walker to furnish all materials and supplies. The contract was not recorded in the office of the Recorder of Mortgages and no bond was required of the contractor. Walker purchased from Markel materials for the price of $209.86, which were used in the work but for which Walker did not make payment. Markel brought this suit seeking solidary judgment against Walker and Mr. and Mrs. Bujol. Walker made no defense but Mr. and Mrs. Bujol denied liability on the ground that Markel had not filed in the office of the Recorder of Mortgages any claim or statement of account, maintaining that under the provisions of the applicable statute, #298 of 1926, such recordation or formal filing of a claim is necessary if the owner of the building is to be held personally liable. There was judgment below against Walker and Mr. and Mrs. Bujol solidarily, and Mr. and Mrs. Bujol have appealed. It is conceded that the statute already referred to is controlling.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.