Louisiana Court of Appeal January 14, 1941, No. 2187. (Perkins v. Hillyer Deutsch Edwards, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1941

OTT, Judge.

The plaintiff was injured while cutting and hewing cross-ties for one Johnnie Cloud on February 13, 1940, and he sues Cloud and Hillyer Deutsch Edwards, Inc., for compensation' at the rate of $11.70 per week for 400 weeks, alleging total permanent disability. Judgment was rendered against Cloud for compensation at the rate of $8.74 per week for a period not exceeding four hundred weeks. The suit was dismissed as to the other defendant. The plaintiff has appealed from that judgment of dismissal, but Cloud has not appealed. So the only question in this case.is whether or not Hillyer Deutsch Edwards, Inc., is liable for compensation to the plaintiff with Cloud. The Hillyer Deutsch Edwards, Inc., is a lumber company operating at Oakdale in Allen Parish, and this company will be referred to as the lumber company.

The plaintiff claims that while he was immediately employed by Cloud, the latter was an agent or contractor of the lumber company in cutting and hauling sawlogs and cross-ties for the lumber company from lands owned by the Rice Land Lumber Company (Rice Institute) of Houston, Texas; that he. was injured while cutting •and hewing ties from this timber.

The contention of the lumber company is that Cloud purchased this timber from the Rice 'Institute, through its agents at Lake Charles, and sold the logs and cross-ties cut therefrom by him to the lumber company for a fixed price for the logs and a fixed price per tie delivered to the lumber company at its mill in Oakdale', that the only relation existing between it and Cloud was that of purchaser and vendor -of the logs and ties at a fixed price delivered at its mill, and that its only connection with the purchase of the timber from the Rice Institute was an agreement to hold out the stumpage of $5 per thousand feet and remit this amount direct to the agents of the Rice Institute.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.