Supreme Court of Minnesota June 6, 1941, No. 32,770. (Bongard v. Nellen)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-06-1941

Stone, Justice.

Replevin for an automobile. On a holding that defendant had a possessory lien, he prevailed below. Plaintiffs appeal from the judgment.

The facts were settled .by'stipulation. As reflected in. the findings, they are these. Plaintiffs now own the ear as conditional vendors after default of the vendee. From January 24 to August lo, 1939, defendant serviced it “pursuant to an agreement” that he was to “put the automobile in question in a good state of repair.”

*393

There is nothing to indicate when, or how, or at what price that desirable objective was to be accomplished.

January 4, defendant did $3.75 worth of work on the car, after which the then owner (the conditional vendee) took it from defendant’s garage, returning it on February 10 for further work. The price of that job was $113.30. The owner again took the car from defendant’s garage and kept it until April 4, when defendant did some work worth $24.25. Again defendant surrendered the car to the owner, who did not return it until June 5, when defendant did some servicing worth $24. As before, the' machine Avas returned to the owner, and he kept it until August 15, Avhen he returned it “for further Avork which was then done amounting to $37.50.” Then, for the first time, defendant retained the car until it Avas taken from him under the writ in this action.

Defendant’s lien is not claimed under the motor vehicle lien laAv. 2 Mason Minn. St. 1927, § 8524. It is based rather upon the general possessory lien statute.

Id.

§ 8507. For a comparison of the tAvo statutes and their operation, see Sundin v. Swanson, 177 Minn. 217, 225 N. W. 15.

Counsel agree that the lien assured by § 8507 is lost by the lienor if he surrenders possession. The statute itself declares that “a voluntary surrender of possession shall extinguish the lien herein given.” Ferriss v. Schreiner, 43 Minn. 148, 44 N. W. 1083; Stebbins v. Balfour, 157 Minn. 135, 195 N. W. 773.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.