Supreme Court of Missouri April 3, 1941 (Hennings v. Hallar)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-04-1941

*830

TIPTON, P. J.

This is an appeal from a judgment of the Circuit Court of -Johnson County, Missouri; setting- aside the will of John P: Ayler, dated September 7, 1938. Throughout this opinion the proponents will be. referred to as the appellants, while the contestants will be referred to as the respondents.

Respondents have filed a motion to dismiss this appeal for the reasons that appellants’ brief does not comply with Section 1060, R. S. Mo. 1929, and our Rule 15, in that it does not contain a clear and concise statement of the facts, and that the assignments of error and points and authorities do- not separately and distinctly enumerate the errors which appellants contend the trial court committed. The statement sets out the substance of the pleadings with a synopsis of the testimony of each witness. Some of the assignments of error, and points and authorities are too general and are subject to respondents’ contention, but the question as to whether the demurrer to the evidence-should have been sustained is sufficiently stated to review the evidence. -The motion to dismiss is therefore overruled.

■ The court’s instructions withdrew from the jury the issue of undue influence and .submitted the case on the issue of mental capacity. Was there any substantial evidence to support the verdict and judg- ■ ment setting aside the will ?

This necessitates a rather full statement of the facts bearing upon the question of mental capacity of the testator, who died October 11, . 1938, at the age of nearly eighty-one. This testator and his younger brother William lived together and neither was married. William .died in the year of 1930, leaving the bulk of his estate to the testator. Testator owned 7-71 acres of land in Johnson County, Missouri, and some real estate in Kansas at the time of his death.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.