Supreme Court of Missouri September 25, 1941 (Edmonds v. City of St. Louis)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-09-1941
*1066
ELLISON, J.
The plaintiff-appellants, who operate restaurants in the City of St. Louis, brought a class injunction suit in the circuit court of that city on November 15,1939, against the defendants-respondents, to restrain them, from enforcing Ordinance 71614, approved June, 20,. 1939, on the ground that it. contravenes Sec. 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment, Constitution of the United, States; six sections of the Missouri Constitution, hereinafter specified; and Secs. 7440 and 7744, R. S. 1939, Secs. 7287, 7596, Mo. Stat. Ann., pp. 5871, 6012. The ordinance levies a license tax of a flat sum per, annum on automatic slot machines set in motion by the deposit of a .coin.or slug in any slot or receptacle attached thereto, and used for .the purpose ,of delivering good,s, wares or merchandise. The appellants use such machines in their restaurants for the sale of package cigarettes, having obtained them from the owners by lease or bailment. The circuit court sustained a demurrer to their petition; they refused to plead further; judgment went against them; and they have appealed.
The first four, assignments contend that the sustention of -the demurrer to the petition was erroneous because it stated a case of discriminatory taxation in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment, and See. 30, Art. II, and Sec. 3, Art. X of the Missouri Constitution. This is on the theory that appellants are also subjected to a license fee of $1 and an occupation tax of $1 per thousand on cigarettes sold, offered or displayed for sale at retail, by another ordinance, No. 41575, approved June 8, 1939, twelve days before the.approval of Ordinance 71.614, supra. Ordinance 41575 is set out in the petition and was sustained by this court in Ploch v. St. Louis, 345 Mo. 1069, 138 S. W. (2d) 1020. But by its own terms it expired on July 1, 1941. Insofar as appellants seek, ¡annulment of Ordinance 71614 and injunction against its enforcement because.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit