Supreme Court of New Jersey May 20, 1941 (Droutman v. the E.L. M. Garage, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-05-1941
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Paekee, J.
Upon the filing of the bill, there was an order for
ad interim
restraint, and to show cause why such restraint should not be continued. Defendants gave notice of motion to strike the bill of complaint, which under present practice is substituted for a demurrer to the bill. Both matters were heard together, and the court ordered the restraint dissolved, motion
*546
to strike the bill granted, and the bill dismissed. The complainant appeals.
The important questions in the case are whether the statute of frauds was applicable to the situation, and if so, whether it was available to respondents on the record.
The facts are adequately stated in the opinion filed by the learned Vice-Chancellor,
ubi supra.
That the agreement relied on by complainant was not in writing, is clear and is not denied. That it would restrict an ordinarily legitimate use' of real property, if enforced, is equally clear. Appellant relies on decisions in Connecticut and Eew York as supporting the proposition that “agreements restricting the use of land, although made by parol, are enforceable and do not come within the statute of frauds,” but no such rule obtains in this state. Our law on this subject was clearly expounded in the Chancery case of
Radey
v. Parr,
108 N. J. Eq. 27,
decided by Vice-Chancellor Learning, one of our ablest Vice-Chancellors. In that case the question was whether an oral agreement by the owner of a tract of land with purchasers of a part thereof that the tract was to be developed and maintained as exclusively residential, would be enforced for the purpose of preventing the erection or operation of a factory on any part of the tract.
On the filing of the bill, there was an order to show cause for restraint, and the argument was on the return of that order to show cause. In that posture of the case an injunction
pendente Hie
was denied (at
p. 88).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit