Supreme Court of New Jersey July 25, 1941 (City of Camden v. Local Government Board)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-07-1941
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Heher, J.
Certiorari
was granted to review the judgment of the defendant Board sustaining the action of the Commissioner of Local Government in refusing approval of the budget adopted by the City of Camden for the year 1940. 125
N. J. L.
73.
The revenue anticipated for the budget year included $60,000 from the sale of real estate theretofore “acquired” by the municipality “for unpaid taxes,” and $50,000 for rents from such properties. The Commissioner deleted the first item, but increased the second to $80,000.
The propriety of the deletion is the sole question at issue. It is defended as the elimination of an improper “item of miscellaneous revenue,” in that “a true anticipated revenue” of that class “under the Budget Act is an item which appears
*176
for the first time in the budget of a given year, not as an-account receivable arising from the transaction of a previous year, but which arises anew in each annual budget; such as interest and costs on delinquent taxes, franchise and gross receipts taxes, fines and penalties, fees and permits, &c.” Thus, a distinction in this behalf is made between “an item which creates a new revenue each year and one which is a recovery of a revenue or an asset which occurred for the first time as such years before.” The former is termed “new annual revenue” and the latter “the liquidation or collection of accounts receivable.” It is said that the sales of “foreclosed properties” do not constitute “new revenues in that particular year, but are recoveries of assets of former years,” and are therefore “not true anticipated miscellaneous revenues as defined in the budget act.”
R. S.
1937, 40:2-15, 40:2-17.
The question is one of statutory construction.
R. S.
1937, 40:2-53, as amended by chapter 396 of the Laws of 1939
(Pamph. L., pp.
943, 946;
N. J. S. A.
40:2-53), invests the Commissioner with jurisdiction to “determine upon the basis of information and data available whether: a.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit