Supreme Court of New Jersey June 18, 1941 (City of Plainfield v. State Board of Tax Appeals)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-06-1941

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Heher, J.

The taxing district of Plainfield assails the judgment of the State Board of Tax Appeals reducing an assessment for taxation for the year 1939 on lands of the defendant Bishop within the district, designated as Nos. 545-609 East Front Street. The assessment totaled =$22,400, apportioned thus: Land, $12,400; improvements, $8,000; garage, $2,000. On the landowner’s appeal, the Union County Board of Taxation reduced the assessment on the improvements from $10,000 to $9,000, and dismissed the appeal from the valuation of the land. The State Board of Tax Appeals, the landowner again appealing, adjudged that the assessment should be as follows: Land, $5,875; improvements, $5,875; garage, $1,000 — a total of $12,750. Thereupon, the taxing district sued out this

certiorari.

*6

It is contended that the judgment of the State Board “is contrary to the evidence” and is based upon the price paid by the landowner for the -property in 1938, rather than “true value” within the'intendment of article IY, section 7, paragraph 12, of the State Constitution and

R. S.

1937, 54:4-23. The assessment and this consideration price are the same.

There is a presumption in favor of the

quantum

of the assessment as made by the local authority, and the

onus

of proof of an - excessive valuation is upon the landowner.

Colonial Life Insurance Co.

v.

State Board of Tax Appeals,

126

N. J. L.

126. The valuation thus placed upon the land 'by the local assessor is at the rate of $52 per front foot. Assessments were laid upon adjacent and comparable lands at a rate ranging between $48 and $53. per front foot, depending upon the depth. So far as is disclosed, these assessments have not been challenged. It would seem as if the State Board considered the price paid by the landowner as conclusive of true value in the accepted sense, and in this it fell into error.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.