Supreme Court of North Carolina May 31, 1941 (Croom v. . Cornelius)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-05-1941

DeviN, J.

The determination of the question of title to the land contracted to be conveyed involves the construction of the will of J. P. Eear-rington. The testator devised his property to his wife and to their three children (one of whom is the plaintiff) in these words: “I wish my estate of whatever nature equally divided among the aforesaid four.” By a

*762

subsequent clause tbe testator added this provision to his will: “In the event that either child die without will, I wish that child’s share to descend to his or her children (share and share alike), or if there are no surviving children to go not to any inlaws or other outsiders, but revert to my other children or grandchildren.”

The provision first quoted contains an unrestricted devise, and nothing else appearing, carried the fee. C. S., 4162;

Heefner v. Thornton,

216 N. C., 702, 6 S. E. (2), 506. In the subsequent clause, the words “in the event that either child die without will, I wish that child’s share to descend to his or her children,” must be held repugnant to the estate previously devised and insufficient to limit or divest it.

Barco v. Owens,

212 N. C., 30, 192 S. E., 862.

The only difficulty arises upon consideration of the latter portion of the clause, which contains this language: “if there are no surviving children ... to revert to my other children or grandchildren.” By these words it is apparent that the testator intended to provide that in the event either of his three children should die without surviving issue, that child’s share should pass to the other children and their lineal descendants. It was admitted that by proper deed all the other devisees under the will have conveyed their interests in the land to the plaintiff.

So

that whether, under the principle enunciated in

Barco v. Owens, supra,

the clause should be disregarded, or whether it should be construed as providing a contingency upon the happening of which the title may be defeated,

Hampton v. West,

212 N. C., 315, 193 S. E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.