Ohio Court of Appeals February 28, 1941, No 5920 (Toohey v. Simmons)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-02-1941

OPINION

By HAMILTON, J.

This appeal is from an order of the Court of Common Pleas, overruling the

*682

motion of the appellant to set aside the confirmation and sale of certain real estate.

The error assigned is that the sheriff in re-appraising the property did so in a manner not in conformity with the order of Court ordering the re-appraisement of the property. It is urged that the sheriff in making the re-appraisement selected three new appraisers to make the new appraisement, in violation of the order of Court, which was “that a re-appraisement be made by the same persons.”

The sheriff in making the re-appraisement selected three new appraisers, who made the appraisement and the sheriff made the return of the appraisement under the value placed by the three new appraisers.

The question is. was that such an irregularity • as would invalidate the sale?

The appellee moves to dismiss the appeal for the reason that the order appealed from is not a final order, from which an appeal can be taken.

If the sale is invalid, it does involve a substantial right, and would be a finality in so far as

the

sale of the property is concerned.

The motion to dismiss the appeal will be overruled.

The question as to the regularity of the appraisement involves §§11672, 11711 and §11688 GC.

Sec. 11672 GC, provides, among other things, that in making the appraisement, “the officer who makes the levy shall call an inquest of three disinterested freeholders, residents of the county where the lands taken in execution are situated, * * *”

This section specifically authorizes the officer making the levy to select the appraisers, and gives no right to the court to make any such selection.

Sec.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.