Oregon Supreme Court September 10, 1941 (Mercep v. State Industrial Accident Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-09-1941

LUSK, J.

This appeal is prosecuted by the defendant, State Industrial Accident Commission, from a judgment in favor of the plaintiff, Matilda Mercep, based on the verdict of a jury awarding the plaintiff compensation on account of the death of her husband, Matt Mercep.

The defendant assigns error in the admission into evidence of certain statements made by the deceased

*462

a short time before his death. They were admitted as dying declarations. The defendant contended in the court below, and contends here, that the evidence was hearsay. The question was raised on the trial by objections to the evidence, motion to strike the testimony from the record, and motion for a directed verdict.

Mercep died on July 4, 1939. The alleged dying declarations were made while he was sick in a hospital in Hillsboro following an operation for hernia. Two or three days before his death he made the following statement to a friend, John Sarabacha:

“He cleaned up a place for cutting for falling timber, that is all he said. There was a limb on the way and he picked that limb and threw it to one side; he says he stepped, when he grabbed that limb, and he stepped on a windfall and his foot slipped; as quick as his foot slipped and threw the limb, just like a pain, pain him right in his stomach. ’ ’

He told his wife while in the hospital:

“He clean out brush and lift a chunk and slipped to the side, he got the pain.”

The precise date of this statement is not shown. Mrs. Mercep saw her husband four times while he was in the hospital, the first time on June 21, the last on ¡June 29. It was on one of these occasions that the statement was made.

Apart from one contention of the defendant, which we find it unnecessary to pass upon, it was a legitimate deduction from this evidence and other facts disclosed that the accident described, which arose out of and in the course of Mercep’s employment, was the proximate cause of hernia and subsequently of his death.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.