Supreme Court of Pennsylvania January 28, 1941, Appeal, 51 (Arnovits v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1941

Opinion by

Mr. Chief Justice Schaffer,

This is an appeal by the Commonwealth in a proceeding brought by plaintiff to recover damages due to the alleged appropriation of a strip of his land in the improvement of a State highway. The position of the Commonwealth is that he does not have title to the strip of land, because years ago it had been acquired by a Turnpike Company. The determination of the issue presented rests on the legal width, of the turnpike. If its width as laid out by the Turnpike Company was fifty feet, plaintiff has no case. If its side lines were only forty-one feet apart, then, in improving the highway, the Commonwealth has taken part of plaintiff’s land and done him considerable injury, as it may be necessary to tear out the front of his building to make it conform to the existing boundary.

Plaintiff’s property is in the Borough of Dunmore and abuts upon what was the Boaring Brook Turnpike, now a State highway, which has been reconstructed. The Turnpike Company was incorporated by the Act of March 29,1867, P. L. 607. This Act makes the Turnpike Company subject to the provisions of the Act of January 26, 1849, P. L. 10, which specifies in Section 11 that the president and managers shall “cause a road, if a turnpike, to be laid out not exceeding fifty feet in width, and cause at least eighteen feet of said width to be made an artificial road.” In the words “not exceed

*151

ing fifty feet in width” is the nub of this controversy. The Commonwealth takes the position that there is a presumption that the turnpike ivas opened to the width of fifty feet and that there is no evidence to rebut such presumption.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.